|
|
| (One intermediate revision not shown.) |
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| - | The '''''New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures''''' (NWT) is a modern-language translation of the [[Bible]] published by the [[Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania|Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society]] in 1961. It is not the first bible to be published by the group, but is their first original translation of ancient [[Biblical Hebrew|Hebrew]], [[Ancient Greek|Greek]], and [[Aramaic language|Aramaic]] biblical texts. As of 2009, the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania has published more than 159 million copies of the Bible in 74 languages.<ref>"Membership and Publishing Statistics", ''JW-Media.org'', [http://www.jw-media.org/people/statistics.htm Authorized Site of the Office of Public Information of Jehovah's Witnesses], As Retrieved 2009-04-10, "Since 1926, the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania has published more than 159 million copies of the Bible in 74 languages."</ref><ref>"How Can You Choose a Good Bible Translation?", ''The Watchtower'', May 1, 2008, page 22, "The New World Translation has been printed in whole or in part in more than 60 languages, with a total printing of more than 145,000,000 copies!"</ref> | + | The New World Bible Translation Committee included the English text from the [[NWT]] in its 1969 and 1985 editions of Kingdom Interlinear Translation of the Greek Scriptures. It also incorporates the Greek text published by Westcott and Hort in The [[New Testament]] in the Original Greek, and a literal word-for-word translation. |
| | | | |
| - | == History ==
| + | {{Donate}} |
| - | Until the release of the NWT, Jehovah's Witnesses in English-speaking countries generally used the ''[[King James Version]]'' or ''[[American Standard Version#Usage of the ASV By the Jehovah's Witnesses|American Standard Version]]'' of the Bible. In the literature they have produced, Jehovah's Witnesses have quoted liberally from the ''King James Version'' and many other translations of the Bible over the years.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | According to the publishers, one of the main reasons for producing a new translation was that most bible versions in common use, including the ''Authorised (King James) Version'', employed archaic language. The stated intention was to produce a fresh translation, free of archaisms. Additionally, over the centuries since the ''King James Version'' was produced, more copies of earlier manuscripts of the original texts in the Hebrew and Greek languages have become available. The publishers claimed better manuscript evidence had made it possible to determine with greater accuracy what the original writers intended, particularly in more obscure passages. They said linguists better understood certain aspects of the original Hebrew and Greek languages than previously.{{Fact|date=April 2009}}
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | In October 1946, the president of the Watch Tower Society, [[Nathan H. Knorr]], proposed a fresh translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures. Work began on December 2, 1947 when the "New World Bible Translation Committee" was formed. On September 3, 1949, Knorr convened a joint meeting of the board of directors of both the Watch Tower Society's New York and Pennsylvania corporations to announce that work on a modern-language English translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures was completed and had been turned over to the Society for printing. It was assigned to the [[Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania]] for publication.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The ''New World Translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures'' ([[New Testament]]) was released at a convention of Jehovah's Witnesses at [[Yankee Stadium (1923)|Yankee Stadium]], [[New York City|New York]], on August 2, 1950. The translation of the Hebrew Scriptures (Old Testament) was released in five volumes in 1953,<ref>''Life'' Magazine, July 1, 1953, [http://www.life.com/image/50317812/in-gallery/ Photo here]</ref> 1955, 1957, 1958, and 1960, and the complete ''New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures'' was released as a single volume in 1961. Since then, it has undergone minor revisions, with the addition of [[Cross-reference|marginal (cross) references]] in 1984. These had been included in the six volumes released between 1950 - 1960 but not in the single-volume editions since 1961.<ref>Foreword, New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures, 1984.</ref> The basic layout style much resembles the American Standard Version 1901 edition.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Translators and Editor===
| + | |
| - | The ''New World Translation'' was produced by the New World Bible Translation Committee. This committee, comprising members of multinational background, was formed about 1947.<ref>''New York Times'', August 3, 1950 p. 19.</ref> The New World Bible Translation Committee requested that the Watch Tower Society not publish names of its members,<ref>[[The Watchtower]], September 15, 1950, p. 320</ref><ref>Walsh vs Honorable James Latham, Court of Session Scotland, 1954, cross examination of Frederick Franz pp. 90-92</ref> stating that they did not want to "advertise themselves but let all the glory go to the Author of the Scriptures, God"<ref>''The Watchtower'', November 15, 1950, p. 454</ref> adding that the translation, "should direct the reader, not to the translators, but to the Bible’s Author, Jehovah God".<ref>''The Watchtower'', December 15, 1974, p. 768.</ref> Jehovah's Witnesses believe that "the particulars of their [the New World Bible Translation Committee's members] university or other educational training are not the important thing" and that "the translation testifies to their qualification".<ref>''The Watchtower'', December 15, 1974, p. 768</ref> Former high ranking Watch Tower staffers have claimed knowledge of the identities of the translators.<ref>Martin W, Kingdom of the Cults, Expanded Anniversary Edition, October 1997, Bethany House Publishers, p. 123. "''While the members of the [NWT] committee have never been identified officially by the Watchtower, many Witnesses who worked at the headquarters during the translation period were fully aware of who the members were. They included Nathan H. Knorr (president of the Society at the time), Frederick W. Franz (who later succeeded Knorr as president), Albert D. Schroeder, George Gangas, and Milton Henschel (currently the president)''."</ref><ref>Wills T, M.A., A People For His Name - A History of Jehovah's Witnesses and An Evaluation, Lulu, 2006. Originally published in 1967 by Vantage Press. "''[Frederick] Franz is a language scholar of no mean ability-he supervised the translation of the Bible from the original languages into the New World Translation, completed in 1961''." (p. 253) Of author Tony Wills, the Preface reads "''The Author has been intimately associated with Jehovah's Witnesses for many years, close enough to be able to think as one, but never, at the same time, losing his objectivity''." </ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | {{BibleHistory}}
| + | |
| - | ==Editions and languages==
| + | |
| - | ===Print editions===
| + | |
| - | The ''New World Translation'' is currently distributed in print editions commonly referred to as "Large Print" (four volumes), "Large Reference", "Regular Pocket-sized Hard Cover", "Regular Pocket-sized Soft Cover", and "Very Small Pocket-sized".<ref>''Jehovah's Witnesses - Proclaimers of God's Kingdom'', published by Jehovah's Witnesses, page 614</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ====Kingdom Interlinear====
| + | |
| - | The New World Bible Translation Committee included the English text from the NWT in its 1969 and 1985 editions of ''Kingdom Interlinear Translation of the Greek Scriptures''. It also incorporates the Greek text published by [[Brooke Foss Westcott|Westcott]] and [[Fenton John Anthony Hort|Hort]] in ''[[The New Testament in the Original Greek]]'', and a literal word-for-word translation.<ref>''Jehovah's Witnesses - Proclaimers of God's Kingdom'', published 1993 by Jehovah's Witnesses, "Chapter 27: Printing and Distributing God’s Own Sacred Word", page 610</ref><ref>"“Between-the-Lines” Translations of the Bible", ''The Watchtower'', November 15, 1969, page 692</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Non-print editions===
| + | |
| - | In 1978, the Watch Tower Society began producing recordings of the NWT on [[audio cassette]],<ref>''Our Kingdom Ministry'', September 1978, page 3</ref> with the entire [[Christian Greek Scriptures]] released by 1981<ref>''Our Kingdom Ministry'', October 1981, page 7</ref> and the [[Old Testament|Hebrew Scriptures]] in three albums released by 1990.<ref>''The Watchtower'', February 15, 1990, page 32</ref> In 2004, NWT was released on compact disc in [[MP3]] format in major languages.<ref>''Watchtower Publications Index 1986-2007'', "Compact Discs"</ref> Since 2008, audio downloads of NWT's Bible books and chapters have been made available from the [http://JW.org Worldwide Association of Jehovah’s Witnesses] website in MP3 and [[Advanced Audio Coding|AAC]] format, including support for [[Podcast]]s.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | In 1983, the English [[Braille]] edition of NWT's Christian Greek Scriptures was released;<ref>''Our Kingdom Ministry'', August 1983, pages 3-4</ref> the complete English Braille edition of NWT was released by 1988.<ref>''Jehovah's Witnesses - Proclaimers of God's Kingdom'', published 1993 by Jehovah's Witnesses, "Chapter 27: Printing and Distributing God’s Own Sacred Word", pages 614-615</ref> NWT editions have since become available in several additional [[Braille#Braille_for_other_scripts|Braille script]]s.<ref>''[[Awake!]]'', November, 2007 p. 30</ref> In 2006, production of the NWT in [[American Sign Language]] began, starting with the [[Gospel of Matthew]].<ref>''2007 Yearbook of Jehovah's Witnesses'', published by Jehovah's Witnesses, pages 21-22</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | [[File:NWT It-diskettes 1993.PNG|thumb|150px|left|A diskette edition of the NWT released at 1993]]
| + | |
| - | In 1992, a digital edition of ''New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures—With References'' was released, as a set of seven 3½-inch 720 KB [[floppy disk|diskettes]] or four 5¼-inch 1.2 MB diskettes, using [[Folio_Corporation#Folio_Versions|Folio View]] software. In 1993, ''New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures—With References/Insight on the Scriptures'' was released in English, as a set of 5¼-inch 1.2 MB or 3½-inch 1.44 MB diskettes, containing the ''New World Translation'' and the two volumes of ''[[Insight on the Scriptures|Insight]]''. Since 1994, NWT has been included in the digital research tool, ''Watchtower Library on CD-ROM'', available to baptized Jehovah's Witnesses.<ref>"The Compact Disc—What Is It All About?", ''Awake!'', April 22, 1994, page 23</ref><ref>''Our Kingdom Ministry'', published by [[Christian Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses]], September 2007, page 3</ref> Since 2007, the full text of the NWT has been available on the [http://www.watchtower.org/bible Watch Tower Society's official website].
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Languages===
| + | |
| - | As of 2009, the NWT has been published in 72 languages.<ref>See ''The Watchtower'' (Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania.) May 1, 2009. p.25</ref> Translation into other languages is based on the English text, supplemented by comparison with the Hebrew and Greek.<ref>Jehovah’s Witnesses—Proclaimers of God’s Kingdom (1993) Chap. 27 p. 611, subheading Translation Into Other Languages.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The complete translation the Holy Scriptures is available in [[Afrikaans]], [[Albanian language|Albanian]], [[Arabic language|Arabic]], [[Cebuano language|Cebuano]], [[Chinese language|Chinese]] (Standard, Simplified, Pinyin), [[Bemba language|Cibemba]], [[Croatian language|Croatian]], [[Czech language|Czech]], [[Danish language|Danish]], [[Dutch language|Dutch]], [[English language|English]] (also Braille), [[Finnish language|Finnish]], [[French language|French]], [[Georgian language|Georgian]], [[German language|German]], [[Greek language|Greek]], [[Hungarian language|Hungarian]], [[Igbo language|Igbo]], [[Ilokano language|Iloko]], [[Indonesian language|Indonesian]], [[Italian language|Italian]], [[Japanese language|Japanese]], [[Korean language|Korean]], [[Macedonian language|Macedonian]], [[Malagasy language|Malagasy]], [[Maltese language|Maltese]], [[Norwegian language|Norwegian]], [[Polish language|Polish]], [[Portuguese language|Portuguese]] (also Braille), [[Romanian language|Romanian]], [[Russian language|Russian]], [[Serbian language|Serbian]] (Cyrillic and Latin scripts), [[Sesotho language|Sesotho]], [[Shona language|Shona]], [[Slovak language|Slovakian]], [[Spanish language|Spanish]] (also Braille), [[Swahili language|Swahili]], [[Swedish language|Swedish]], [[Tagalog language|Tagalog]], [[Tsonga language|Tsonga]], [[Tswana language|Tswana]], [[Turkic language|Turkish]], [[Twi]], [[Xhosa language|Xhosa]], [[Yorùbá language|Yoruba]], and [[Zulu language|Zulu]].
| + | |
| - |
| + | |
| - | The Christian Greek Scriptures (commonly known as the New Testament) is available in [[American Sign Language]], [[Amharic]], [[Armenian language|Armenian]], [[Brazilian Sign Language]], [[Bulgarian language|Bulgarian]], [[Cambodian language|Cambodian]], [[Chichewa language|Chichewa]], [[Efik language|Efik]], [[Ewe language|Ewe]], [[Hiligaynon language|Hiligaynon]], Italian Braille, [[Kinyarwanda language|Kinyarwanda]], [[Kirghiz language|Kirghiz]], [[Kirundi language|Kirundi]], [[Lingala language|Lingala]], [[Luganda language|Luganda]], [[Myanmar language|Myanmar]], [[Ossetic language|Ossetic]], [[Samoan language|Samoan]], [[Sepedi language|Sepedi]], [[Sinhalese language|Sinhala]], [[Slovene language|Slovenian]], [[Sranan Tongo|Sranantongo]], [[Thai language|Thai]], and [[Ukrainian language|Ukrainian]].
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | {{Jehovah's Witnesses}}
| + | |
| - | ==Features of the translation==
| + | |
| - | Various editions of the ''New World Translation'' have been published. The 1984 reference edition has more than 125,000 cross references, running headings at the top of most pages to assist in locating texts, footnotes about translation decisions, an index, and several appendices further discussing various translation decisions. Some of the footnotes also add transliterations from the original languages. The pronoun "you" is printed in [[small capitals]] to indicate plurality, as are some verbs when plurality may be unclear. Square brackets [ ] are added around words that were inserted editorially (double brackets are used to indicate sources considered doubtful).
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The translation includes the name ''Jehovah'' over 200 times in the New Testament as a substitute for references to God, when in the original Greek and Hebrew the name Jehovah was never used.<ref>http://www.iclnet.org/pub/resources/text/cri/cri-jrnl/crj0049a.txt</ref> The basis offered by the translating body is that since the name Jehovah was used liberally in the original Greek and Hebrew manuscripts of the Old Testament, it can be assumed that the lack of references to Jehovah in the New Testament were an oversight on the part of the ancient manuscript writers.<ref>The Divine Name That Will Endure Forever p. 24</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The standard (not reference) edition is printed in smaller type on thinner paper, lacks the footnotes, and adds a "Bible Topics for Discussion" section that outlines where to find scriptures about various doctrinal points. An even smaller "pocket edition" also lacks the cross-references.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | There are various appendices in the different editions published, including arguments for various translation decisions, extra data on certain aspects of manuscripts, conversion tables for weights and measures, an agricultural calendar, maps, and diagrams of the tabernacle and temple. Many of the non-English translations lack the footnotes, and some add footnotes specific to translation into their languages.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The translators use the terms "Hebrew-Aramaic Scriptures" and "Christian Greek Scriptures" rather than "Old Testament" and "New Testament", stating that the use of "testament" was based on a misunderstanding of 2 Corinthians 3:14.<ref>Appendix 7E in the New World Translation reference edition</ref> When referring to dates in the supplemental material, the abbreviations B.C.E. (before the common era) and C.E. ([[common era]]) are used rather than BC and [[AD]].
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Verbs indicating continuous or progressive action are consistently rendered as such in English, for example "proceeded to rest" rather than "rested" in Genesis 2:2, or "keep on asking" rather than "ask" at Matthew 7:7.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ==Critical review==
| + | |
| - | ===Overall review===
| + | |
| - | In its review of bible translations released from 1955 to 1985, ''The HarperCollins Bible Dictionary'' listed the ''New World Translation'' as one of the major modern translations.<ref>Robert G. Bratcher, "English Bible, The" ''The HarperCollins Bible Dictionary'' (revised and updated edition of ''Harper's Bible Dictionary'', 1st ed. c1985), HarperCollins Publishers/The Society of Biblical Literature, 1996, p. 292.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | In 2003 [[Jason BeDuhn]], associate professor of religious studies at Northern Arizona University in the United States, published a 200-page study of nine of “the Bibles most widely in use in the English-speaking world,” including the [[New American Bible]], [[The King James Bible]] and The [[New International Version]]. His study examined several passages of Scripture that are controversial, where “bias is most likely to interfere with translation”. For each passage, he compared the Greek text with the renderings of each English translation, and he looked for biased attempts to change the meaning. BeDuhn states that the general public and many Bible scholars assume that the differences in the New World Translation (NW) are due to religious bias on the part of its translators. However, he states: “Most of the differences are due to the greater accuracy of the NW as a literal, conservative translation.” While BeDuhn disagrees with certain renderings of the New World Translation, he says that it emerges as the most accurate of the translations compared,” calling it a “remarkably good” translation.<ref>BeDuhn, Jason D. ''Truth in Translation: Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament'', 2004. BeDuhn compared the ''King James'', the ''(New) Revised Standard'', the ''New International'', the ''New American Bible'', the ''New American Standard Bible'', the ''Amplified Bible'', the ''Living Bible'', ''Today's English'' and the ''NWT'' versions in Matthew 28:9, Phillipians 2:6, Colossians 1:15-20, Titus 2:13, Hebrews 1:8, John 8:58, John 1:1.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Old Testament===
| + | |
| - | Samuel Haas, in his review of the first volume of the ''NWT of the Hebrew Scriptures'', in the ''Journal of Biblical Literature'', stated that “this work indicates a great deal of effort and thought as well as considerable scholarship, it is to be regretted that religious bias was allowed to colour many passages.”<ref>''Journal of Biblical Literature,'' Vol. 74, No. 4, (Dec. 1955), p. 283.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Professor [http://jewishhistory.huji.ac.il/Profs/HU/History/kedar.htm Benjamin Kedar], a Hebrew scholar in Israel, said in 1989: “In my linguistic research in connection with the Hebrew Bible and translations, I often refer to the English edition of what is known as the New World Translation. In so doing, I find my feeling repeatedly confirmed that this work reflects an honest endeavor to achieve an understanding of the text that is as accurate as possible.”<ref>Interview quotation as cited by: "The Bible in Modern Times", ''“All Scripture Is Inspired of God and Beneficial”'', ©1990 Watch Tower, page 326</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Regarding the NWT’s use of English in the first volume of the first volume of the NWT (''Genesis to Ruth''), Dr. Harold H. Rowley is critical of what he calls “wooden literalism” and “harsh construction.” He characterizes these as “an insult to the Word of God” and offers a few sample renderings from Genesis. Specifically he cites Genesis 15:5, 4:13, 6:3, 18:20, 4:8, 19:22, 24:32 and 24:66. Rowley concludes these criticisms by writing, “From beginning to end this volume is a shining example of how the Bible should not be translated.”<ref>Rowley, H.H., How Not To Translate the Bible, The Expository Times, 1953; 65; 41</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===New Testament===
| + | |
| - | Theologian and televangelist [[John Ankerberg]] accused the translators of rendering the NWT to conform "to their own preconceived and unbiblical theology."<ref>See Ankerberg, John and John Weldon, 2003, ''The New World Translation of the Jehovah's Witnesses'', accessible [http://www.johnankerberg.org/Articles/ATRI-Bible-School/Fall-Bible-School/fall-bible-school-jw-new-world-translation.htm online], which quotes a number of scholars regarding alleged theological bias of the New World Translation.</ref> To support a view of theology overriding appropriate translation, Drs. [[John Ankerberg]] and John Weldon cite several examples, such as the NWT's use of "for all time" in Hebrews 9:27: “And as it is reserved for men to die once for all time, but after this a judgment.” Ankerberg and Weldon cite Dr. Julius Mantey on this text as saying, “Heb. 9:27, which without any grounds for it in the Greek, is mistranslated in the J. W. Translation… the phrase “for all time” was inserted in the former versions without any basis in the original for it.”<ref>See Ankerberg, John and John Weldon, 2003, ''The New World Translation of the Jehovah's Witnesses'', accessible from [http://www.johnankerberg.org/Articles/ATRI-Bible-School/Fall-Bible-School/fall-bible-school-jw-new-world-translation.htm this site], which quotes a number of scholars regarding alleged theological bias of the New World Translation.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | [[William Barclay (theologian)|Dr. William Barclay]] concluded that "the deliberate distortion of truth by this sect is seen in the New Testament translation…. It is abundantly clear that a sect which can translate the New Testament like that is intellectually dishonest."<ref>Rhodes R, The Challenge of the Cults and New Religions, The Essential Guide to Their History, Their Doctrine, and Our Response, Zondervan, 2001, p. 94</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | [[Edgar J. Goodspeed]], translator of the Greek “New Testament” in An American Translation, wrote in a letter to the Watchtower Society: “I am interested in the mission work of your people, and its world wide scope, and much pleased with the free, frank and vigorous translation. It exhibits a vast array of sound serious learning, as I can testify.”<ref>“Loyally advocating the Word of God,” ''The Watchtower'' (15 March, 1982), p. 23.</ref> In regard to whether the NWT can be recommended to the general public, Goodspeed replied, "No,I'm afraid I could not do that. The grammar is regrettable. Be careful on the grammar. Be sure you have that right."<ref>Cetnar & Cetnar,1983:58</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | <!--Greek scholar Dr. Rijkel ten Kate notes in reference to the NWT that in rendering different Greek words (''bre′phos'', ''pai‧di′on'', and ''pais'') employed to describe the successive stages of Jesus’ growth “that there is actually one Dutch Bible in which the different use of the three Greek words bre′phos, pai‧di′on, and pais is rightly taken into account,” after having previously reviewed other Dutch translations and concluded that “not one Dutch translation has rendered this adequately, that is to say, completely in harmony with the original text.”<ref>''The Watchtower'', April 15, 1995</ref> [Not a review of the NT, but a specific comment on brief and uncontroversial verses]-->
| + | |
| - | Dr. [[Bruce Metzger]] stated for the ''NWT of the Greek Scriptures'' that "on the whole, one gains a tolerably good impression of the scholarly equipment of the translators."<ref name=Metzger>Metzger, Bruce M, The New World Translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures, ''The Bible Translator'' 15/3 (July 1964), p. 151.</ref> However, Metzger also cites NWT renderings as instances of translating to support doctrine, stating, "the Jehovah's Witnesses have incorporated in their translation of the New Testament several quite erroneous renderings of the Greek."<ref>Bruce M Metzger, "Jehovah's Witnesses and Jesus Christ," Theology Today, (April 1953 p. 74); see also Metzger, "The New World Translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures," The Bible Translator (July 1964) </ref> He cites the NWT’s comma placement at Luke 23:43 as “In the interest of supporting the doctrine of "soul sleep" held by Jehovah’s Witnesses.”<ref>Metzger, Bruce M, Persistent Problems Confronting Bible Translators, Bibliotheca Sacra / July-September 1993: 279</ref> Another example Metzger offers is the insertion of the word “other” four times in Colossians chapter 1 “thus making Paul say that Jesus Christ is one among ‘other’ created things.” Of this insertion, Metzger states it is “In the interest of providing support of [Jehovah’s Witnesses’] Unitarianism” and that the insertion is “totally without warrant from the Greek”.<ref>Metzger, Bruce M, The New World Translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures, The Bible Translator 15/3 (July 1964), pp. 150-153.</ref> Dr. Bruce Metzger characterizes the NWT’s use of “Jehovah” in the New Testament as an “introduction.” He writes, “The introduction of the word ‘[[Jehovah]]’ into the New Testament text, in spite of much ingenuity in an argument filled with a considerable amount of irrelevant material (pp. 10–25), is a plain piece of special pleading.”<ref>Metzger, Bruce M., The New World Translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures, The Bible Translator 15/3 (July 1964), pp. 150-153.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | [[Charles Francis Potter]] has stated about the NWT: "Apart from a few semantic peculiarities like translating the Greek word ''stauros'', as "stake" instead of "cross," and the often startling use of the colloquial and the vernacular, the anonymous translators have certainly rendered the best manuscript texts, both Greek and Hebrew, with scholarly ability and acumen."<ref>''The faiths men live by,'' Kessinger Publishing, 1954, 239. ISBN 1425486525.</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | [[Reachout Trust]] writer Tony Piper concludes it is not a "faithful translation of the Scriptures…", giving as examples Acts 2:42, 46 and 20:7, 11 and he objects that “the NWT translates it to read that the church simply shared meals together” rather than using the phrase “breaking of bread [...] to disguise the fact that the early church celebrated the Lord's Supper more than once a year.” <ref> Tony Piper, member of Reachout Trust examines the New World Translation http://www.reachouttrust.org/articles/jw/jwnwt.htm</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Hebrew and Greek scholar [[Alexander Thomson (scholar)|Alexander Thomson]] wrote: “The translation is evidently the work of skilled and clever scholars, who have sought to bring out as much of the true sense of the Greek text as the English language is capable of expressing. ... We heartily recommend the New World Translation of the Christian Greek Scriptures, published in 1950 by the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society.”<ref>Thomson A, ''The Differentiator'', 1952, 55,57 No. 2, 6</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Thomas Winter considers the ''Kingdom Interlinear Translation of the Greek Scriptures'' (part of the NWT project) as a “highly useful aid toward the mastery of koine (and classical) Greek”. Winter relates that the translation "is thoroughly up-to-date and consistently accurate.”<ref>Thomas N. Winter, Review of New World Bible Translation Committee’s The Kingdom Interlinear Translation of the Greek Scriptures, Classics and Religious Studies Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department, University of Nebraska – Lincoln, April-May 1974: 376</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Case study of translation===
| + | |
| - | One of the NWT's most controversial passages is [[John_1:1#Difficulties|John 1:1]]. The ''King James Version'' translation renders this verse:<ref>http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John%201%20;&version=9;</ref>
| + | |
| - | <blockquote>In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the ''Word was God''.</blockquote>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The ''New World Translation'' renders the same verse:<ref>http://www.watchtower.org/bible/joh/chapter_001.htm</ref>
| + | |
| - | <blockquote>In [the] beginning the Word was, and the Word was with God, and the ''Word was a god''.</blockquote>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The absence of the definite article (''ho'') in the second occurrence of the word ''theos'' before the verb in the sentence in Greek is considered significant. Translators who insist on rendering John 1:1, “The Word was God,” do not hesitate to use the indefinite article (a, an) in their rendering of other passages where a singular anarthrous predicate noun occurs before the verb. Thus at John 6:70, The ''Jerusalem Bible'' and ''King James'' both refer to Judas Iscariot as “a devil,” and at John 9:17 they describe Jesus as “a prophet.”
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | The NWT's rendering is considered by many as a change to agree with the [[Beliefs and practices of Jehovah's Witnesses|doctrines of Jehovah's Witnesses]]. Some reference books argue strongly that the Greek text must be translated, “The Word was God”, however not all agree.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | In his article, “Qualitative Anarthrous Predicate Nouns: Mark 15:39 and John 1:1”, Philip B. Harner said that such clauses as the one in John 1:1, “with an anarthrous predicate preceding the verb, are primarily qualitative in meaning. They indicate that the logos has the nature of theos.” He suggests: “Perhaps the clause could be translated, ‘the Word had the same nature as God.’”<ref>''Journal of Biblical Literature'', 1973, pp. 85, 87</ref> Of the NWT’s rendering “…and the Word was a god” at John 1:1, Metzger states it “is not justifiable” and “entirely in accord with the Arian theology of the sect.”<ref name=Metzger />
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Dr J R Mantey, of the Chicago Northern Baptist Theological Seminary, in reference to the NWT of John 1:1 said it is "a shocking mistranslation. Obsolete and incorrect. It is neither scholarly nor reasonable to translate John 1:1 'The Word was a god.'"{{Fact|date=May 2009}}
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Dr. Jason BeDuhn, states of the NWT that its “translation of John 1:1 is superior to” the other translations he considered. He continues, “It may well be that the NW translators came to the task of translating John 1:1 with as much bias as the other translators did. It just so happens that their bias corresponds in this case to a more accurate translation of the Greek. ... The NW translation of John 1:1 is superior to that of the other eight translations we are comparing. I do not think it is the best possible translation for a modern English reader; but at least it breaks with the KJV tradition followed by all the others, and it does so in the right direction by paying attention to how Greek grammar and syntax actually work.”<ref>BeDuhn, Jason D. ''Truth in Translation: Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament'', 2004: 125, 133</ref>
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | Several other bible translations render [[John 1:1#Translation|John 1:1]] in a similar manner:
| + | |
| - | *1808 “and the Word was a god” - ''The New Testament, in An Improved Version, Upon the Basis of Archbishop Newcome’s New Translation: With a Corrected Text'', London.
| + | |
| - | *1864 “and a god was the Word” - ''The Emphatic Diaglott'' (J21,interlinear reading), by Benjamin Wilson, New York and London.
| + | |
| - | *1935 “and the Word was divine” - ''The Bible—An American Translation'', by J. M. P. Smith and E. J. Goodspeed, Chicago.
| + | |
| - | *1955 “so the Word was divine” - ''The Authentic New Testament'', by Hugh J. Schonfield, Aberdeen.
| + | |
| - | *1978 “and godlike sort was the Logos" - ''Das Evangelium nach Johannes'', by Johannes Schneider, Berlin.
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | {{See also|John 1:1}}
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ==References==
| + | |
| - | {{reflist|2}}
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ==Further information==
| + | |
| - | ===Online Edition===
| + | |
| - | *[http://www.watchtower.org/bible/index.htm New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures] - Watchtower Society official web site
| + | |
| - | *[http://www.jw.org/index.html?option=QrYQZRQVNlVlYR New World Translation to download as audiobook]
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Supportive===
| + | |
| - | *Stafford, Greg: ''Jehovah's Witnesses Defended''. [ISBN 0-9659814-7-9]
| + | |
| - | *[[Rolf Furuli|Furuli, Rolf]]: ''The Role of Theology and Bias in Bible Translation: With a special look at the New World Translation of Jehovah's Witnesses'', 1999. [ISBN 0-9659814-9-5]
| + | |
| - | *Byatt, Anthony and Flemings, Hal (editors): ''‘Your Word is Truth’, Essays in Celebration of the 50th Anniversary of the New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures (1950, 1953)'', 2004. [ISBN 0-9506212-6-9]
| + | |
| - | *[http://jehovah.to/exe/translation/coptic.pdf The Coptic Evidence]
| + | |
| - | * [http://web.archive.org/web/20071218010255/mysite.wanadoo-members.co.uk/newworldtranslation/home.htm In Defense of the New World Translation]
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Neutral===
| + | |
| - | *[[Jason BeDuhn|BeDuhn, Jason]]: ''Truth in Translation - Accuracy and Bias in English Translations of the New Testament'' [ISBN 0-7618-2556-8]
| + | |
| - | *[http://www.lectio.unibe.ch/05_2/troyer_names_of_god.htm The Names of God. Their Pronunciation and Their Translation. A Digital Tour of Some of the Main Witnesses.]
| + | |
| - | *[http://www.tetragrammaton.org/ Tetragrammaton in the New Testament]
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | ===Critical===
| + | |
| - | * Robert Countess: ''Jehovah's Witnesses' New Testament: A Critical Analysis'', [ISBN 0-87552-210-6]
| + | |
| - | * [http://www.evangelicalbible.com/jw.htm NWT and the Deity of Christ - A table showing NWT changes to key Christological passages, written from an evangelical perspective]
| + | |
| - | * [http://www.catholicresponse.org/articles/Hiding_The_Divine_Name.pdf Hiding the Divine Name] Article critical of the ''Kingdom Interlinear Translation''
| + | |
| - | {{English Bible translation navbox}}
| + | |
| - | | + | |
| - | [[Category:1961 books]]
| + | |
| - | [[Category:Bible versions and translations]]
| + | |
| - | [[Category:Jehovah's Witnesses literature]]
| + | |
1 ·
